Overall: 7.5 of 10 Great pre owned condition with some signs of use.
Outside: Only gentle signs of use.
Inside: Very clean and only gentle signs of use.
Vernis leather: Some light signs of use. Some small gray and deep beige dots and spots, not too noticeable (mostly around the zipper opening). One side of the zipper opening has a deeper more yellow shade from tanning. A single small red dot on the bottom. The back of the bag has a thin black scuff mark on the right edge.
Cowhide leather: Looks clean with patina/color and some signs of use ( gentle scratches and very faint water stains).
Shape: Keeps its shape well.
Edges: Very light signs of use.
Hardware: Signs of use. The gold-tone is a deeper shade with some gold coating wearing off a bit.