Overall: 7.5 of 10 Great pre owned condition with some signs of use.
Outside: Some signs of use.
Inside: Very clean with light signs of use.
Cowhide leather: Deeper patina/color, scratches, scuffs, lines and water stains. The tops of the leather handles are a deeper shade with some heavy scuffs. Both leather leaves on the sides of the bag have surface cuts and tears and may eventually tear off.
Fabric: Some signs of wear. The denim monogram looks great with only light signs of wear.
Shape: Keeps its shape well.
Edges: Light signs of use (gentle scuffs).
Hardware: Nice and shiny with some tiny dots of tarnishing.
Smell: Faint Perfume/cosmetic smell. If you are very sensitive to smells please keep this in mind before you decide to purchase this pre-owned product.
Extra comments: Both leather leaves on the sides of the bag have surface cuts and tears and may eventually tear off.