Overall: 7.5 of 10 Great pre owned condition with some signs of use.
Outside: Some signs of use.
Inside: Clean but has some light signs of use. Mostly clean with just some dark grey, glue like residue on the underside of the flap for the flap pocket.
Canvas: Light signs of use. A few tiny white marks from scuff on one side of the bag. The rest of the canvas looks great.
Cowhide leather: Deeper patina/color, scratches, scuffs, lines, grey scuffs, and water stains. The shoulder straps have softened from use and are a deeper shade from being held.
Shape: Keeps its shape but has light signs of use. A bit flat when empty.
Edges: Signs of use (scuffs, dark shade).
Hardware: Signs of use. The gold-tone is a deeper shade with some gold coating wearing off the tips of the studs and the front push lock, making some areas look silver than gold.
Smell: Damp & musty smell. If you are very sensitive to smells please keep this in mind before you decide to purchase this pre-owned product.