Overall: 7 of 10 Great pre owned condition with some visible signs of use.
Outside: Some signs of use.
Inside: Some signs of use. The inside of the small pouch is damaged and sticky. For the main bag: few small brown marks here and there but mostly spotless.
Canvas: Light signs of use. Few faint grey scuff like marks but barely noticeable.
Cowhide leather: Deeper patina/color, scratches, visible scuffs, lines and water stains. Few faint grey marks on the straps from the buckles and some thin surface cracks (straps are still functional).
Shape: Keeps its shape but has light signs of use. Has softened and does not stand upright on its own.
Edges: Signs of use (scuffs, light fading on bottom edge).
Hardware: Signs of use. The gold-tone is a deeper shade with some gold coating wearing off a bit.The bottom feet have some tarnishing.
Smell: Free of smell.
Extra comments: The inside of the main bag is fully functional and mostly spotless but the inside of the small pouch is damaged and sticky.