Overall: 7.5 of 10 Great pre owned condition with some signs of use.
Outside: Some signs of use.
Inside: Clean but has light signs of use. Light brown stains along the inside edges of the slip pockets, the rest of the bag is clean.
Leather: Some visible signs of use. Few surface scratches, gentle gray marks, and a gray scratch/scuff mark on the bottom of the bag. Lines on the straps.
Cowhide leather: Deeper patina/color, gentle scratches, lines and water stains. Some pinprick sized holes/dents on the underside of the straps, but barely noticeable.
Shape: Keeps its shape nice and stiff with very gentle use.
Edges: General signs of use ( light scuffs).
Hardware: Nice and shiny with gentle signs of use.
Extra comments: 2 light surface scratches on the bottom of the bag