Overall: 7.5 of 10 Great pre owned condition with some signs of use.
Outside: Some visible signs of use.
Inside: Very clean with light signs of use.
Vernis leather: Some visible signs of use. The yellow shade has deepened and looks closer to a yellow gold. The leather under the front flap has visible discoloration/fading but it cannot be seen when the bag is closed.
Cowhide leather: Deeper patina/color, scratches, scuffs, lines and water stains. A dark mark on the strap from the buckle.
Shape: Keeps its shape well.
Edges: Signs of use (scuffs).
Hardware: Nice and shiny with light signs of use.
Smell: Closet smell. This is a pre-owned item and will not smell brand new. If you are very sensitive to smells please keep this in mind before you decide to purchase this product.
Extra comments: The bag looks great overall but the yellow has deepened to a more yellow gold shade and there are some visible discoloration underneath the front flap.